Make a Payment
Otterstedt offers a variety of ways to pay your bill. Please find below a listing of our carriers’ phone numbers and website addresses. If you pay Otterstedt directly for your insurance, please contact our office at 201-227-1800 and speak to either our Accounting Department or your Account Executive. If you are billed directly by your insurance company, please contact them by phone or visit their website. We are always available to assist you with any questions, concerns, or changes.
| Carrier: | Phone Number: | Web Site: | |
| AIG Company | 1-800-645-2259 | Personal | www. |
| Allianz/Firemans Fund | 1-800-882-6919 | Commercial | billing@agcs.allianz.com |
| Andover Ins Company | 1-800-225-0770 | Commercial | www.vuebill.com/Andover/Login.aspx |
| C.N.A. Ins Company | 1-877-276-7507 | Commercial | www.cnacentral.com |
| Chubb | 1-800-682-4822 | Personal | www.chubb.com/us-en/log-in/individual-payment-login.aspx |
| Chubb Ins Company | 1-800-37-Chubb | Commercial | www.chubb.com |
| Delos Ins Company | 1-888-654-3100 | Commercial | no website |
| Encompass | 1-866-430-2916 | Personal | www.encompassinsurance.com/billpay/login.aspx |
| Farmers Mutual of Salem | 1-800-498-0954 | Commercial | www.farmersofsalem.com |
| Firemans Fund | 1-800-261-9497 | Personal | www.firemansfund.com/policyholder |
| FMI | 1-800-336-3642 | Personal | www.fmiweb.com |
| FMI Ins Company | 1-800-842-0551 | Commercial | www.fmiweb.com |
| Great American Ins Co | 1-800-847-4357 | Commercial | www.greatamericaninsurance.com |
| Guard Ins Company | 1-800-673-2465 | Commercial | https://www.guard.com/payments/ |
| Hanover | 1-800-573-1187 | Personal | www.hanoverinsurance.com/thg/tools/payment_options.htm |
| Hanover Ins Company | 1-800-922-8427 | Commercial | www.myhanoverpolicy.com |
| Harleysville | 1-866-665-4992 | Personal | www.harleysvillegroup.com |
| Harleysville Ins Company | 1-866-665-4992 | Commercial | www.harleysvillegroup.com |
| Hartford Ins. Company | 1-800-962-6170 | Commercial | www.thehartford.com |
| KB Insurance Company, Ltd. | 1-201-720-2100 | Commercial | www.kbicus.com |
| NJ Skylands Insurance | 1-866-279-7688 | Commercial | www.njsi.com |
| One Beacon Ins Company | 1-877-434-3900 | Commercial | www.onebeacon.com |
| Palisades Ins Company | 1-877-COM.Only opt 4 | Commercial | www.palisades.com |
| Peerless Ins Company | 1-800-218-1340 | Commercial | www.peerless-ins.com |
| Philadelphia Ins Co | 1-877-438-7459 | Commercial | www.phly.com |
| Plymouth Rock Assurance | 1-800-696-2858 | Personal | https://ci2.plymouthrock.com/eservice/login |
| Plymouth Rock Assurance | 1-800-696-2858 | Commercial | www.plymouthrock.com |
| Progressive | 1-800-876-5581 | Personal | www.progressiveagent.com/manage-your-policy.aspx |
| Selective | 1-888-974-7400 | Personal | www.selective.com |
| Selective Ins Company | 1-800-777-9656 x 2100 | Commercial | www.selective.com |
| Tower Group Companies | 1-800-441-3369 | Commercial | www.twrgrp.com |
| Travelers | 1-877-872-8651 | Personal | www.mytravelers.com |
| Travelers Ins Company | 1-800-252-2268 | Commercial | www.travelers.com |
| Zurich Ins Company | 1-800-800-3907 | Commercial | www.zurichna.com |
