Start Saving the Smart Way Now!

Enter Email Below for a Quote

Enter Email Here for a quote:

About Us

Following a tradition of excellence. Leading with experience.

100 years of history—and 1000s of satisfied clients to show for it. Since1919, when Fred H. Otterstedt founded the company, we’ve had a special tie to the families, individuals, and businesses we serve. In 1955 Joe Parisi Sr. purchased the agency from Mr. Otterstedt and, together with his wife Lucille and son Joe Parisi Jr., built one of the tri-state area’s leading insurance agencies, while maintaining the personal focus we began with. Our current President, Bob Casazza, continues to build on this tradition.

Read more about our history.

We’re good folks with high I.Q.s (that’s Insurance Quotients.) The experience and passion of every Otterstedt professional have given our clients incredible insights into their current and future insurance needs over the years. We don’t just sell insurance. Anyone can do that. We help our clients make important and informed decisions every day when it comes to protection and their future.

Read our insurance FAQs.

Recently recognized as one of the Top 50 Insurance Agencies in the country. A unique balance of value, experience and personalized services set Otterstedt apart from other insurance agencies. Maybe that’s why generation after generation of families and businesses have stayed our clients.

Surveys show Otterstedt consistently has some of the most competitive rates available. Our standing in the industry gives us access to the best insurance companies in the country. That reputation enables us to get you the most competitive prices and policies tailored exactly to your needs.

A Trusted Choice® Agent committed to our neighbors’ success. The passion and experience of every dedicated Otterstedt professional give our clients incredible insight into their current and future needs and help guide them to the best possible decisions. We believe when you have the right coverage, price, and relationship, you can achieve peace of mind.

Talk to an Otterstedt representative. And follow the leader.

Companies We Represent. View More >

  • Plymouth Rock Logo
  • Hartford Insurance Logo
  • Hanover Insurance Logo
  • Travelers Insurance Logo
  • Harleysville Insurance Logo
  • Selective Insurance Logo
  • Chubb Insurance Logo
  • ISU Logo