Start Saving the Smart Way Now!

Enter Email Below for a Quote

Enter Email Here for a quote:


Otterstedt Insurance Agency
84 BroadwayDenville, NJ  07834
Tel: 908-273-2422 Fax: 201-227-5031
Hours of Operation: 9:00am to 5:00pm Monday through Friday
John Nufriol Headshot

John Nufrio, Vice President / Branch Manager
Find me on Facebook
Connect on LinkedIn

Otterstedt Insurance Agency’s Denville branch is an excellent example of the type of businesses that make Denville, New Jersey such a vibrant community in which to build a home, open a business, and raise a family. Our Denville branch is an ever-present neighbor the community relies upon over through thick and thin as a trusted insurance provider.

Our Branch Manager/ Vice President John G. Nufrio, CIC, and his expert team work diligently to provide exceptional insurance options and competitive rates. The Branch traces its far-reaching roots in the community to the prestigious Holmes Agency, which was, founded in 1896, and Otterstedt acquired in 1996.

Since its birth, the branch has built on the agency’s service excellence tradition. It’s grown into the leading regional player it is today. The branch offers outstanding access to top insurance carriers, as well as state-of-the-art insurance products and services offered by Otterstedt.

Our Denville branch carries the same commitment to deep roots that the Otterstedt Insurance Agency has with a strong focus on the tradition of personal service that resonates with all our branches. Check out our Facebook page to see for yourself.

Denville Branch Services

We offer a comprehensive range of personal and business insurance products to meet the diverse needs of the local community and beyond. Our in-depth experience and veteran expertise enables us to offer specialized insurance products for condos, restaurants, contractors, real estate agencies, nonprofit organizations funeral homes, and more.

Personal Insurance Products

Otterstedt Insurance Agency offers personal insurance products designed to help you protect your investments and personal interests, including the following:

  • Health Insurance – including disability insurance, group health, long-term care, and employee benefits.
  • Home Insurance – including condo, co-op, renter’s, townhouse, vacation home, and flood insurance coverage.
  • Life Insurance – including annuities and estate planning.
  • Auto Insurance – including motorcycle insurance
  • Recreational Vehicles Insurance- including ATV, Boat, Jet Ski, Mobile Home and Snowmobile insurance.

Commercial Insurance Products

As an insurance agency dedicated to local businesses, we offer a wide range of commercial insurance products, including the following:

  • Building Insurance
  • Business Interruption Insurance
  • Business Personal Property Insurance
  • Commercial Auto
  • Employee Benefits
  • General Liability
  • Manufacturing
  • Workers’ Compensation Coverage

Industries We Serve

Though we work with those in every industry, we especially cater to those in the construction, pest control, real estate, restaurant, retail areas, in addition to school boards, human resources companies, non-profit, and public entities. Our professional insurance services extend to accountants, attorneys, consultants, physicians, and more.

Financial Services

In addition to the many insurance products we offer, we specialize in financial services including estate planning, annuities, investments, and 401k products. Our financial services and products are designed to protect your investments while at the same time maximize your profitability.

The Otterstedt Insurance Agency is one of the leading agencies in the tri-state area – largely as a result of our steadfast commitment to personal connections.

Call the Otterstedt Insurance Denville Branch at 908-273-2422 today to discuss your insurance needs and to see how we can help you get the right insurance protection to meet those needs.

Companies We Represent. View More >

  • Plymouth Rock Logo
  • Hartford Insurance Logo
  • Hanover Insurance Logo
  • Travelers Insurance Logo
  • Harleysville Insurance Logo
  • Selective Insurance Logo
  • Chubb Insurance Logo
  • ISU Logo