It's About
People

Not Policies

We don’t just sell you a policy. Insurance, like people, come in different shapes and sizes and we are here to help you personalize your insurance needs.

Get a Quote

About Us

Insurance for Individuals

Exceptional insurance for extraordinary lives.
Learn more >

Insurance for Businesses

Choose an insurance partner that makes your protection and profitability their main priority.
Learn more >

Surety Bonds

Surety solutions for specific requirements or multiple bonding needs.
Learn more >

Start Saving the Smart Way Now!

Read The Otterstedt Blog

Does My Business Insurance Cover Flood Damage?

There are many perils involved in owning a business today. For this reason, many business owners purchase various commercial insurance policies. Unfortunately, many are surprised and dismayed to learn, only after they need to file a claim, that among the perils not covered by their many insurance policies is a flood. In fact, you need […]

Read Blog Post

Testimonials

Excellent insurance company, Joseph Nasello has been my agent for over 30 years, would not have anyone else. He is there for me when I have any concerns...

Vincent C
Otterstedt has always been extremely responsive and helpful in figuring out any potential issues I may have. The team offers options and best solutions when circumstances arise or change.

Richard S
The staff I have dealt with were always very helpful, informative and willing to go the extra mile for you. Great agency.

Daniel Q
Polite, quick to respond and excellent customer service! Have gone out of their way to get things done in the past and present!!!

Gary B

Contact Us

It's AboutPeople