It's About
People

Not Policies

We don’t just sell you a policy. Insurance, like people, come in different shapes and sizes and we are here to help you personalize your insurance needs.

Get a Quote

About Us

Insurance for Individuals

Exceptional insurance for extraordinary lives.
Learn more >

Insurance for Businesses

Choose an insurance partner that makes your protection and profitability their main priority.
Learn more >

Surety Bonds

Surety solutions for specific requirements or multiple bonding needs.
Learn more >

Start Saving the Smart Way Now!

Read The Otterstedt Blog

If a Neighbors Tree Falls onto Your Property, What is Covered By The Neighbor's Insurance Policy?

Trees. They are beautiful in the spring and fall, provide valuable shade in the summer, and break the wind when winter’s worst blows bitter cold into your home. Tall trees with big branches offer perfect locations for tree houses, tire swings, and endless hours of summer fun for kids of all ages. But what happens […]

Read Blog Post

Testimonials

Excellent insurance company, Joseph Nasello has been my agent for over 30 years, would not have anyone else. He is there for me when I have any concerns...

Vincent C
Otterstedt has always been extremely responsive and helpful in figuring out any potential issues I may have. The team offers options and best solutions when circumstances arise or change.

Richard S
The staff I have dealt with were always very helpful, informative and willing to go the extra mile for you. Great agency.

Daniel Q
Polite, quick to respond and excellent customer service! Have gone out of their way to get things done in the past and present!!!

Gary B

Contact Us

It's AboutPeople