Start Saving the Smart Way Now!

Enter Email Below for a Quote

Enter Email Here for a quote:


Otterstedt Insurance Agency
363 Cedar LaneTeaneck, NJ  07666
Tel: 201-836-2100 Fax: 201-227-5026
Hours of Operation: 9:00am to 5:00pm Monday through Friday

Sheryl Overbey, AIS, CPIW
Teaneck Branch Manager
Find me on Facebook
Connect on LinkedIn

With more than 80 years of experience under our belt and an open-door policy, the Teaneck branch of Otterstedt Insurance Agency is a great mix for the diverse and eclectic group of people that call Teaneck, New Jersey home.

With such a diverse group of people in the community drawing from different experiences, cultures, religions, and backgrounds, working with an insurance agency, like Otterstedt Insurance Agency, that can build insurance plans to meet the specific needs of each family or business is a good plan.

The Teaneck branch can trace its roots back to 1926. While we do believe that it’s important to hold on to the traditions that have carried us this far, we also believe in looking to the future. This means we have a wide range of modern insurance products and technology to make the entire process, from start to finish, easier, while holding true to the same traditional values and face-to-face that have been part of our organization for nearly 100 years.

Personal Insurance Products Available in Teaneck

The Otterstedt way of insurance is committed to providing Teaneck families with the protection you need without draining your pocketbook. We offer a wide range of products to help you protect your home, family, interests, and other property.

Home Owner’s Insurance

Your home is your place of sanctuary from the world. Whether you’re renting or you own a home, condo, townhome, duplex, or co-op, you need adequate insurance coverage to help you restore your home to normal quickly in the aftermath of a covered event.

Automobile Insurance

In the state of New Jersey, auto insurance is not an option. However, the rules concerning auto insurance and what is actually best for you are not always the same thing. Let us help you select the policy that best meets your needs as a driver today.

Life Insurance and Financial Planning

Life insurance is all about making sure the people you leave behind are cared for if you’re no longer here to take care of them yourself. Whether you’re caring for aging parents, just getting started in life, or have children of your own, we have the right life insurance policies to meet your current needs and to deal with changes in circumstance as they arise. We are also happy to help with your estate planning, investment, and annuity needs too.

Teaneck Branch Commercial Insurance Products

We also understand that local businesses help make our community strong. We have the coverage you need to protect your business interests now and as it grows. Don’t forget to contact us to review your existing business insurance to see if you’re adequately covered for the needs of businesses operating in a modern society, including:

General Liability Coverage

In today’s litigious society, no business can afford to operate without the protection liability insurance coverage provides to assist with court costs as well as judgments made against your business.

Business Property Coverage

When covered events happen, business property insurance helps with the cost of repairing damage to the buildings, grounds, and signage while also replacing lost inventory, furniture, fixtures, computers, and equipment.

Business Interruption Insurance

When your business is out of service due to a covered event, business interruption insurance helps to replace the income lost during this critical time.

Business Auto Coverage

When business owned vehicles are in accidents or stolen, this insurance becomes critical if you have delivery drivers or employees who conduct business in personal vehicles, you should also look into the value of liability coverage for non-owned vehicles too.

Workers’ Compensation Coverage

If you have employees, then you need workers’ compensation coverage. Not only is it the law of the land in New Jersey, but it also provides critical protection for your employees and your business.

We can even handle a wide range of employee benefits that includes group health benefits, disability, long-term care insurance, 401ks, and more.

Our Teaneck office also serves nearby towns such as Ridgefield Park, Bogota, Hackensack.

Otterstedt Insurance Agency’s Teaneck branch is all about building relationships. Call us today at 201.836.2100 with all your personal and business insurance questions and see what a difference our personal touch makes.

Companies We Represent. View More >

  • Plymouth Rock Logo
  • Hartford Insurance Logo
  • Hanover Insurance Logo
  • Travelers Insurance Logo
  • Harleysville Insurance Logo
  • Selective Insurance Logo
  • Chubb Insurance Logo
  • ISU Logo