Start Saving the Smart Way Now!

Enter Email Below for a Quote

Enter Email Here for a quote:

File a Claim

Otterstedt’s experienced and professional claim staff stands ready to assist you with reporting and seeing you through the process every step of the way. Please feel free to call us at 201-227-1800 during business hours or email claims@otterstedt.com.

However, if you choose, the information provided below gives you the opportunity to contact your insurance company directly, either by telephone or online. For emergency services (such as water damage and “board-up”), we have also included restoration companies for you to contact.


AIG Insurance

www.aig.com

1-877-399-6442

Personal Insurance 1-888-760-9195 (office)

            -1-866-858-1475 (fax)

Business Insurance – 1-866-642-5246


Allstate

https://www.allstate.com/claims/file-track


American Modern Insurance

 www.amig.com

1-800-375-2075 (office)

1-513-947-4040 (fax)


AmTrust

https://amtrustfinancial.com/claims

1-888-239-3909


Andover Insurance Companies

www.andovercos.com

1-800-225-0770 (office)

1-800-323-5112 (fax)


Assurant Flood

https://www.assurant.com/claims-and-support/overview

1-800-423-4403


Chubb Group of Insurance Companies

www.chubb.com

1-800-252-4670 (phone);

1-800-300-2538 (fax)

Online Reporting:

http://www.chubb.com/claims/report-a-claim.html


CNA

https://www.cna.com/web/guest/cna/claim-center


Crum & Forster

http://www.cfins.com/claims/report-a-claim/

1-800-690-5520


Cumberland

https://www.cumberlandmutual.com/report-a-claim-3


Encompass Insurance

http://www.encompassinsurance.com/claims/main.aspx

1-800-588-7400


Farmer’s of Salem

http://www.farmersofsalem.com/report_claim_lan.aspx

1-856-935-1851

1-800-498-0954 #3


Foremost

https://claims.foremost.com/cmp/s/filealoss?SO=03


Franklin Mutual

1-800-336-3642 (option 2)

https://www.fmiweb.com/html/claim_form.cfm


Guard Insurance Group

www.guard.com

1-888-639-2567


Hanover Insurance Group

https://www.hanover.com/report-claim-online

1-800-628-0250


Harleysville/Nationwide

https://www.nationwide.com/personal/insurance/claims/harleysville/

1-800-892-8877

Harleysville Flood – 1-800-892-8877


The Hartford Insurance Company

https://www.thehartford.com/claims

1-800-243-5860

Hartford Flood – 1-800-759-8656


Liberty Mutual

https://www.libertymutual.com/claims-center

1-800-225-2467


Mercury Insurance

http://www.mercuryinsurance.com/insurance-claims/how-to-file-insurance-claim.html

1-800-503-3724 x4


Met Life

https://www.metlife.com/support-and-manage/file-a-claim/

1-800-854-6011


Narragansett Bay

https://www.nbic.com/claims/

phone: 1-800-343-3375 Option 2, then 1

fax: 4-1-401-721-0700

Email: claimsmail@nbic.com


National General

https://claims.nationalgeneral.com/report

1-800-468-3466


New Jersey Manufacturers

www.njm.com

1-800-367-6564 (all lines)

Personal Insurance  1-800-232-6600

Workers’ Compensation – 1-800-435-7656 (M-F 8am – 5pm)

Commercial Auto – 1-800-367-6564


NJ Skylands

https://www.njsi.com/services-claims/

1-888-855-4622


Norfolk & Dedham

https://www.ndgroup.com/claims-services

1-800-688-1825


Ohio Casualty

https://business.libertymutual.com/claims/


Peerless Insurance

www.peerless-ins.com

 1-800-522-7152


Penn National Insurance

https://www.pennnationalinsurance.com/claims/report-a-claim/

1-800-766-2245

Workplace injury Reporting 1-800-374-4990


Philadelphia Insurance Company

https://www.phly.com

1-800-765-9749 (phone)

1-800-765-9749 #3 (CAT Phone)

1-800-685-9238 (fax)


Plymouth Rock Assurance f/k/a Palisades Insurance Co

https://www.plymouthrock.com/claims

1-844-346-1225


Preferred Mutual

https://www.preferredmutual.com/claims/report-a-claim

1-800-333-7642


Progressive

https://www.progressive.com/claims/

1-800-776-4737


Safeco

https://www.safeco.com/claims

1-800-332-3226


Scottsdale Insurance Company 

https://nationwideexcessandsurplus.com

1-800-423-7675 (option 1)


Selective Insurance Company

https://www.selective.com/claims-center

1-866-455-9969


Travelers

https://www.travelers.com/claims/report-claim/index

Personal Insurance (Auto, Home, Personal Property, Boat and Yacht): 1-800-252-4633

Business Insurance (Auto Property, General Liability, Specialty and Workers Comp): 1-800-238-6225


UFG

https://www.ufginsurance.com/report-a-claim


Universal Property and Casualty

https://universalproperty.com/claims


USLI

https://www.usli.com/support

1-888-523-5545


Restoration Companies

NamePhoneWebsite
Arrow AutoGlass1-866-975-4527www.arrowautoglass.com
Servpro of West Essex & Union1-877-887-5306www.servpro.com
Servpro Teaneck Englewood1-201-266-0482http://www.servproteaneckenglewood.com/
Alternate Phone1-201-953-9318
Servpro of S. Jersey City/Bayonne1-201-333-3200http://www.servprosouthjerseycitybayonne.com
Servpro of Northwest Bergen1-201-236-2400http://www.servpronorthwestbergen.com
Allan Industries – Headquarters1-888-333-7933allanidustries.com
Puro Clean1-908-577-9120www.puroclean.com/rs-nj
Alternate Phone1-609-685-5109
Belfor1-732-317-4500www.belforusa.com
IRS1-800-634-0261www.irs-restoration.com
Alternate Phone1-732-558-5732
Paul Davis Restoration-Main Office1-866-233-4737pauldavis.com
Emergency Phone1-888-473-7669
Gemini1-877-774-3646www.geminirestoration.com
Alternate Phone1-908-686-7777
Astro Care1-973-334-0053
First Onsite1-800-622-6433https://firstonsite.com/
Alternate Phone1-973-338-6767
Restorecore1-888-988-2769www.restorecore.com  (can report claim online)
Alternate Phone (NJ)1-732-5121010
Rapid Recovery1-866-505-5600www.rapidrecoveryservices.net
Office Phone1-201-505-0600
Service Master1-888-443-6100www.servicemastermetro.com

Companies We Represent. View More >

  • Plymouth Rock Logo
  • Hartford Insurance Logo
  • Hanover Insurance Logo
  • Travelers Insurance Logo
  • Harleysville Insurance Logo
  • Selective Insurance Logo
  • Chubb Insurance Logo
  • ISU Logo