Start Saving the Smart Way Now!

Enter Email Below for a Quote

Enter Email Here for a quote:

Pompton Plains

Otterstedt Insurance Agency
933 Route 23 SouthPompton Plains, NJ  07444
Tel: 973-616-2811 Fax: 201-227-5039
Hours of Operation: 9:00am to 5:00pm Monday through Friday
John Lawrence Headshot

John Lawrence
President of Pompton Plains
Find me on Facebook
Connect on LinkedIn

Bryan Hyland Headshot

Bryan Hyland
Surety Division Manager
Find me on Facebook
Connect on LinkedIn

Michael Cronin Headshot

Michael Cronin
Surety Specialist
Find me on Facebook
Connect on LinkedIn

Martin Kelly Headshot

Martin Kelly
Insurance Specialist

Otterstedt Insurance Agency has grown into one of the Tri-State area’s leading providers of surety and construction insurance thanks to the significant industry expertise supplied by our team at the Pompton Plains branch.

Offering a full-suite of commercial and personal insurance products, Otterstedt’s Pompton Plains branch is proud to serve all families who call Pompton Plains and the surrounding townships, neighborhoods, and communities home.

Commercial Insurance at Otterstedt’s Pompton Plains Branch

Pompton Plains, NJ is a community of homes and businesses. We’re committed to helping protect those businesses that make our community a great place to call home. Otterstedt Insurance Agency offers a wide range of products for businesses of all shapes and sizes, including the following types of insurance coverages.

  • Business Property
  • Business Interruption
  • Business Auto
  • General Liability
  • Professional Liability (Errors and Omissions)
  • Workers’ Compensation

Personal Policies in Pompton Plains

We understand that you are all unique with individual interests, needs, and lifestyles. We believe we have the perfect insurance products for all residents to meet their lifestyle today, and as it changes over time, with our personal insurance products. By offering state of the art insurance products and technology with out of this world service before and after the sale, we believe we’re the perfect choice for your insurance needs as they are today and in the future.

Auto Coverage

If you’re a driver in New Jersey then you need auto coverage. We can explain the ins and outs in order to help you make the right decision for your current situation and insurance needs.

Home Insurance

Your home may be the single largest investment you ever make. Protect that investment and the love that has been poured into your home with the appropriate amount of insurance protection for your home and the belongings inside. The caring professionals at the Pompton Plains branch of Otterstedt Insurance Agency can help you make important decisions about your home insurance coverage.

Life Insurance

The decision to buy life insurance for some can be quite difficult. It’s hard to consider what life will be like for your family if you’re no longer there to provide for them. But making the decision today can spare them financial hardship that could otherwise compound their grief over your passing. You can’t replace yourself, but you can leave your family the ability to survive the financial trials ahead and to take the time they need to grieve – a gift that truly is priceless.

Our Pompton Plains branch serves Passaic and Morris counties, including the nearby towns of Pompton LakesWayneKinnelon, and Pequannock.

The Pompton Plains, NJ, Otterstedt Insurance Agency branch has deep roots and a strong commitment to tradition and history. Call us today at: 973.616.2811 to learn about our personal and business insurance products and to see what we can do for you.

Companies We Represent. View More >

  • Plymouth Rock Logo
  • Hartford Insurance Logo
  • Hanover Insurance Logo
  • Travelers Insurance Logo
  • Harleysville Insurance Logo
  • Selective Insurance Logo
  • Chubb Insurance Logo
  • ISU Logo