Start Saving the Smart Way Now!

Enter Email Below for a Quote

Enter Email Here for a quote:


Otterstedt Insurance Agency
1001 Route 517Suite 1 Allamuchy, NJ  07840
Tel: 201-841-1147 Fax: 201-227-5031
Hours of Operation: 9:00am to 5:00pm Monday through Friday
Randy May Headshot

Randy May, Branch Manager

Otterstedt Insurance Agency understands the importance of staying true to your roots.  There are more than 4,000 people who call Allamuchy home who all have unique needs when it comes to insurance for home or business.

Personal Insurance Protection in Allamuchy

Otterstedt Insurance Agency’s Allamuchy branch can help you identify and meet all of your insurance coverage needs while treating you with the warmth and respect you deserve.

Because we work with people from all walks of life and who have diverse income goals, financial planning, and insurance needs, we can easily create a coverage plan that is customized to your specific and unique insurance needs for the following types of insurance and more.

Home Insurance

For many Allamuchy residents your home is your comfort zone. It doesn’t matter if you’re new to the community or in your third generation, you want to protect the investment you make in your home and the possessions inside your home. We offer home insurance coverage for renters and homeowners alike for a wide range of housing choices including co-ops, condos, townhomes, vacation homes, and more.

Auto Insurance

It comes as no surprise to most New Jersey residents that auto insurance is a must. And yet many people find themselves confused by the many options for auto coverage. Talk to us today and let us help you sort through your auto insurance options to choose the one that’s best for your situation and budget. Of course, we also offer vehicle coverage for motorcycles, classic cars, antique automobiles, and ATVs as well.

Health Insurance

It doesn’t get much more personal than health insurance. The Allamuchy branch of Otterstedt Insurance Agency is happy to offer group health insurance along with other employee benefits, financial planning, long-term care coverage, and more for your good health today and in the future.

Flood Insurance

Don’t forget the importance of flood insurance for your New Jersey home or business. Standard insurance policies for homes or businesses do not protect your property from the damages floods leave behind. You’ll need a specific flood policy for your home or business and their contents.

Commercial Insurance by Otterstedt at Allamuchy

Businesses in Allamuchy need insurance coverage too. The very basic coverage your business needs is a business owners’ policy, or BOP. This policy is offers basic business coverage needs, such as business property insurance, general liability insurance, and business interruption insurance at deeply discounted rates.

This isn’t the sum total of insurance coverage businesses need. We also offer essential coverage options for businesses that includes:

  • Business Auto Insurance
  • Commercial Auto Insurance
  • Business Personal Property Insurance
  • Workers’ Compensation Insurance
  • Employee Benefits (this includes group health policies, disability insurance, annuities, investing, and 401k).

The Allamuchy branch of Otterstedt Insurance Agency is the newest branch, having opened in 2005, but offers values consistent with the Otterstedt name, and its 100-year history serving New Jersey’s insurance needs. Despite our timeless commitment to providing superior customer service, the Allamuchy branch offers modern conveniences and takes advantage of state of the art technology for a better overall experience.

Call our Allamuchy branch today at 201.841.1147 to discuss your situation or to have us look over your existing policy to see if you have the insurance coverage you need for your home or business.

Companies We Represent. View More >

  • Plymouth Rock Logo
  • Hartford Insurance Logo
  • Hanover Insurance Logo
  • Travelers Insurance Logo
  • Harleysville Insurance Logo
  • Selective Insurance Logo
  • Chubb Insurance Logo
  • ISU Logo