Welcome to Otterstedt Insurance Agency, making insurance personal since 1919! You're one step closer to discovering our Five Star Difference. Just complete this brief form and one of our trusted advisors will be in touch with you shortly.

    Request a FREE Quote

    Read Our Reviews

    • All of your representatives are friendly, helpful, knowledgeable and will answer any/all questions that you may have.

      Claire B.
    • Excellent! Great service, so helpful and the best premium.

      Spectrum Doors & Windows
    • It feels great to know someone has your back and will fight for you...Otterstedt does that for us and we are grateful for all of their help!

      Kate B.
    • Very pleased with the experience and service provided by Otterstedt Insurance Agency.

      Mario G.
    • Thorough, pleasant experience working with Otterstedt Agency!

      Janet R.

    Companies We Represent. View More >

    • Plymouth Rock Logo
    • Hartford Insurance Logo
    • Hanover Insurance Logo
    • Travelers Insurance Logo
    • Harleysville Insurance Logo
    • Selective Insurance Logo
    • Chubb Insurance Logo
    • ISU Logo