Local Branches

Return to Homepage

Allamuchy
Hours: Daily 9–5
1000 Route 517, Suite 1
Allamuchy, NJ 07840
201.841.1147 - phone
201.227.5031 – fax
allamuchy@otterstedt.com

High tech resources and high touch service define our Allamuchy Branch.

Randy May
Branch Manager
rmay@otterstedt.com

The Allamuchy Branch of Otterstedt Insurance is a study in contrasts. Opened in 2005, Allamuchy is our newest branch backed by one of New Jersey’s oldest insurance agencies. Being part of Otterstedt with its 90-year history gives Allamuchy access to some of the best insurance providers—and rates—in the country. On the flip side, being new makes it one of our most modern branches and a leader in cutting edge processes and state-of-the-art services.

Another dichotomy of this branch is its client base from opposite ends of the spectrum. The branch, led by industry veteran Randall W. May, has gained a reputation for customizing insurance plans and programs for the special needs of individuals and large entities alike.

Every commercial and individual client receives the same personalized service from Randy and his team. That has made it a powerhouse in the local area, as well as in the New Jersey business community. And considering the countryside surroundings of the office, that may be the biggest surprise of all. See our Facebook page for even more color on the branch.

Whether you’re looking for a contrast to your current insurance provider or starting new, Allamuchy is a beautiful place to begin. Arrange a review of your needs by calling 201-841-1147 or emailing.