File a Claim

Return to Homepage

Having a claim can be a stressful event. We're here to help.

Otterstedt’s experienced and professional claim staff stands ready to assist you with reporting and seeing you through the process every step of the way. Please feel free to call us at 201-227-1800 during business hours or email claims@otterstedt.com. However, if you choose, the information provided below gives you the opportunity to contact your insurance company directly either by telephone or online.

Ace Private Risk Services - www.aceprivateriskservices.com/irene
1-800-945-7461

American Modern Insurancewww.amig.com
1-800-375-2075

Andover Insurance Companieswww.andovercos.com
1-800-225-0770 (phone)

Chartis Insurance - www.chartisinsurance.com
Personal Insurance - 1-888-760-9195
Business Insurance - 1-866-642-5246

Chubb Group of Insurance Companieswww.chubb.com
1-800-252-4670 (phone); cscfnol@chubb.com (email)

CRC Insurance Services
1-205-986-6384 (fax); ireneclaims@crcins.com (email)

Encompass Insurancewww.encompassinsurance.com
1-800-588-7400 (phone); 1-866-286-5221 (fax with Acord);
CAT Claim Center 1-800-340-3016 (phone); 1-888-262-0912 (fax)

Farmer’s of Salemwww.farmersofsalem.com
1-800-498-0954 and press 3 for claims department

Fireman’s Fund Insurance Companywww.firemansfund.com
1-888-347.3428

Franklin Mutualwww.fmiweb.com
973-948-3120 (phone); 973-948-7190 (fax)

Guard Insurance Groupwww.guard.com
1-888-639-2567

Hanover Insurance Group www.hanover.com
1-800-628-0250 (phone); 1-800-399-4734 (fax); firstreport@hanover.com (email)
Or submit a claim online: http://www.hanover.com/thg/tools/report.htm

Harleysvillewww.harleysville.com
1-800-892-8877
Or submit online www.harleysvillegroup.com/app_OnlineClaims/

Harleysville Flood
– 1-800-759-8656

The Hartford Insurance Companywww.thehartford.com
1-800-243-5860

Hartford Flood
- 1-800-637-3846

Jimcor
201-573-8820 (fax); claimsfirstreports1@jimcor.com (email)

Mercury Insurancewww.mercuryinsurance.com
1-800-503-3724 x4; 1-877-533-6330 x1

New Jersey Manufacturerswww.njm.com
Personal Insurance – 1-800-232-6600
Workers’ Compensation – 1-800-435-7656 (M-F 8am – 5pm)
Commercial Auto – 1-800-367-6564

One Beacon Insurancewww.onebeacon.com
1-877-248-3455

Peerless Insurancewww.peerless-ins.com
1-800-522-7152

Penn National Insurancewww.pennnationalinsurance.com
1-800-766-2245

Philadelphia Insurance Companywww.phly.com
1-800-685-9238

Plymouth Rock Assurance f/k/a Palisades Insurance Company
1-877-725-6423 (phone); 1-908-790-7856 (fax); claimreports@plymouthrock.com (email)

Selective Insurance Companywww.selective.com
1-866-455-9969 (phone); 1-877-352-6541 (fax for new P&C losses); 1-877-352-6860 (fax for new WC losses); WCFNOL@selective.com (email for WC only); CVSCENTER@selective.com (email for losses other than WC)

Selective Flood  - www.myselectiveflood.com
1-877-348-0552 (phone); 973-948-3311 (local phone);
1-877-647-1798 fax; email claims to floodclaims@selective.com

Tower Group
1-888-856-5522 (phone);  1-888-291-6262 (fax); First Report E-Mail: reportaloss@twrgrp.com

Travelerswww.travelers.com
Personal Insurance (Auto, Home, Personal Property, Boat and Yacht): 1-800-252-4633
Business Insurance (Auto Property, General Liability, Specialty and Workers’ Comp): 1-800-238-6225
Or submit business claims online: https://clclaimreporting.travelers.com/clrpt/logonagent.asp

Travelers Floodwww.mytravelersflood.com
1-800-505-0193